Trailstone Insurance Group Reviews

“Worked well with my work schedule and was able to do most stuff through text”

“Cody made it very easy to change insurance companies. As a bonus, I saved money and got better coverage.”

“Gabe Fritz was great to work with at Trailstone! He gave our family some great options to choose from and was very knowledgeable through the process. Gabe was not only able to help save us money on our home and auto, he was also able to get us better coverage! If you’re shopping coverage, make sure to give Gabe a shout!”

“Just did my homeowners insurance with Trailstone Insurance. Sylvie Shook did an incredible job of shopping around and finding me best rates. She also walked me through the entire policy and explained everything so clearly. She's professional, patient and Incredibly helpful. Highly recommend !!!”

“Never had a worse experience with a company. Beware! They’ll treat you well the first year, after that it’s almost impossible to even get hold of them. Long long story short I may have to report them to BBB.”

“Cody has been great to work with. I saved quite a bit moving my home and auto over and the process has been super easy.”

“After more than a decade with American Family Insurance, I reached my breaking point with rates creeping up year after year across our home, auto, and umbrella policies. Every annual sit-down with our previous agency ended the exact same way. The only way to lower the bill was cutting away real protection, which was never an acceptable answer for my family. I decided it was time to shop the independent market, so I connected with Gabe at Trailstone Insurance Group through the RamseyTrusted network. Before having Gabe run the numbers, I took time to clean up our underwriting profile. My married daughter was set up on her own policy at her new home, an old phantom vehicle finally came off our umbrella schedule, and I laid out non-negotiables for solid medical payments, better auto rental limits, and legitimate replacement cost coverage. Gabe took all of that and went to work, assembling a tailored multi-carrier package. He placed our home with The Hartford, bundled our auto and travel trailer through Progressive, set up our umbrella with RLI, and layered in a supplemental Sola policy to take the bite out of Colorado's brutal wind and hail deductibles. Truth be told, the final numbers blew me away. The new setup slashed our annual insurance costs by several thousand dollars while drastically improving our actual coverage. I sent over a clean, respectful cancellation notice to our old agent, and politely declined their last-minute offer to pick apart the competitor paperwork. Our former carrier wrapped up the cancellations, sent out four separate unearned premium refund checks, and closed out the transition without a hitch. If you are tired of paying more for less, Gabe and the team at Trailstone prove that working with a sharp independent broker makes all the difference.”

“I have had a great experience with Trailstone Insurance Group. They found an insurance plan exactly as I requested, and thoroughly helped me throughout the whole process. Brian does a great job communicating everything.”

“Via a recommendation from one of my neighbors, I have been using Trailstone for the last two years. During my first year, they walked me through all my options, including bundling, standalone, and even cherry picking to get the best rate possible. In year two, they were on top of the automatic renewal and even found me a better price by switching providers. Most recently, they helped me add on my new car to my current policy the same day that I bought the vehicle. Morgan & Gabe are extremely easy to work with, I absolutely recommend.”

“I had a great experience with Jesse from Trailstone Insurance Group. My previous insurance company raised my insurance rate by $2000 over the prior year. Jesse found me a new policy with much better coverage and it saved us $3400!! It was very easy to switch!! You can save yourself time and money by letting Trailstone Insurance Group do a policy review for you!!”

“Trevor at Trailstone was phenomenal! He saved us over $6000 per year. He was prompt , had accurate information, and patient when gathering all the information for our quote.”

“I needed a fast change in auto insurance brokers as prices were rising so quick and communication was limited. Since finding Andrew Tierranegra with Trailstone, all questions have gone answered. He has done the work to find me the best options and has been very open and transparent of what needs to be done. I would definitely recommend Trailstone to others!”

“Trevor was exceptional and a true customer service professional. He was super patient, knowledgeable and genuine whenever we spoke, working with me in spite of my touch-and-go schedule. He answered all of my questions with sincerity and care and explained everything thoroughly. He also found the most comprehensive auto insurance coverage for me at the best price, getting a way better quote than when I had been shopping around independently; he even sent a video quote with a comprehensive explanation of the plan he’d deemed to be the best deal/rate and why, additionally offering to hop on a call if I had any further questions. From our first phone call, Trevor felt like someone I could trust—his sincerity shines through, and I genuinely feel like he had my best interests at heart while working with him. I will definitely be calling him in the future and also referring him to anyone else who is looking for a quality broker in Colorado.”

“Trailstone was great. I found what I needed and was treated well by my agent. They answered all of my questions, which I greatly appreciated.”

“I have the pleasure of working with Trevor Johnson. He was very helpful and patient as we worked through my insurance needs. I will be recommending him to others.”

“I had a really good experience working with Trevor to find more affordable car insurance. He was very honest and transparent and did not pressure me at all. I did, in fact, move my vehicles to a policy he found.”

“My experience with Trailstone Insurance Group has been nothing but positive. I worked with Michael B who was attentive, helpful, and walked me through many options. They were able to get me more affordable and better coverage policies for my two vehicles. Highly recommend to anyone thinking of potentially changing plans or venturing into the market for the first time. Go with these people and they will take care of you.”

“I was looking for new homeowners because we kept getting premium increases. Found Trailstone and am so happy I did. Christy was so helpful and personable! Worked with us to find cheaper insurance and still the same coverage. She walked us through each step and was very patient with questions.”

“Amber Clendening was incredibly helpful when I needed to change the address for my renters insurance when I moved! There were some technical issues with whatever program the insurance company uses to make the change, so Amber helping to get in touch with the people there to get the change to go through properly before I needed to sign my rental contract was a tremendous help!! (In case anyone is looking for reviews about the insurance rates/policies, this 5-star review is only meant to reflect the customer service I received)(I don't have much knowledge of what makes a policy good/cost-effective so I am not the right person to look to for advice about that)”

“I wish to highlight Amber Clendening for her diligent legwork and her exceptional "digging" skills to find a respected insurance company to fill my needs!!! Thank you, Amber!!”

“I had the best insurance experience with Shannon Glover. In this day of AI and technology, it was so nice to have a personal connection with a human that also speaks English! Shannon delivered excellent customet service, saved me around $300 on my auto insurance with even better coverage! I highly recommend Trailstone”

“Professional. Great communicator. All around good to work with.”

“Easy process. Christy was a pleasure to work with. Great way to save money.”

“Trailstone insurance was great! I started looking to get better prices and I was connected with them through the Dave Ramsey trusted pros program. Trailstone helped me save money on my home and auto. Working with them was quick, informative and easy! Trevor from Trailstone answered all my questions and guided me through the process. He provided me with all the information I needed to make the best decision for my situation!”

“Just hopped off a phone call with Amber, she was extremely helpful, and got me a quote immediately after we got off the phone. Thanks again for the help!”

“Trailstone’s work on my behalf has greatly reduced the stress of searching for the best fit for my insurance needs. I am relieved to know they will annually shop my needs to many providers to find the best fit and price.”

“Great insurance company to do business with. Exceptional customer service. Highly recommend”

“Was super helpful and was able to meet with me outside of normal business hours which was great!”

“Working with Gabe at Trailstone Insurance was such a positive experience. He was always on time for meetings and quick to respond to my questions and concerns. Glad I found this company and am able to benefit from their services.”

“We have loved working with Jimmy! When we decided to shop around to see if any other insurance was cheaper than the one we had, Jimmy helped answer all of our questions and helped us to find a better deal. He has been super knowledgeable and been great at getting back to us with any questions that we have. We look forward to continue working with Jimmy!”

“Grant Leach was a pleasure to deal with. He beat all my other quotes, followed thru when needed, was professional and personal. His knowledge was exceptional and he was patient when explaining terms, laws etc. Grant is certainly a gem in the insurance industry.”

“I worked with Andrew at TIG, he was very knowledgeable and explained everything every step of the way. I highly recommend!”

“Talked to Ben. Great guy. Super helpful in directing me to PA resource. If i was in CO, i would hire him.”

“Sylvie Shook was great to work with and helped our household save money on both our home and auto by switching with Trailstone. We saved thousands per policy period and are so pleased.”

“Professional, attentive, flexible with the clients needs and I always found in available whenever I have confusion with my insurance related queries and concerns.He is the best.”

“Awesome service, very professional, and has the ability to shop the market for the best available coverage at the best price! Highly recommend this agency!!”

“Been working with Robyn for a while now and finally have been able to set up a time we can go over rates and she saved me over 300 a month on my Car insurance. 5 star all day long.”

“I was looking for an insurance company that could help reduce my home and car insurance payments, and Trailstone was very helpful. My agent Josh took the time to find me good coverage at a better price and made the whole process easy. I’m very happy with the service and truly appreciate their help. Thank you!”

“Brian at Trailstone was incredibly helpful! My EV insurance rate was extremely high, but he took the time to find me a much more manageable and affordable option. He made the entire process easy and stress-free. I highly recommend Brian and Trailstone to anyone looking for better insurance rates and excellent customer service!”

“I had a great experience working with Jesse and his team. Jesse took the time to understand what I actually needed for my auto insurance and was able to help me get better coverage while also lowering my premium. What stood out most was how knowledgeable, responsive, and straightforward he was throughout the process. I never felt pressured, and he made sure I understood my options before making any decisions. I would definitely recommend Jesse and his team to anyone looking for an insurance agent who genuinely takes the time to look out for his clients. Great service and a great experience overall!”

“Matt was great to work with, friendly, knowledgeable, and fast.”

“for years I let my home and auto insurance policies just auto renew while the premiums crept up. I saw some rave reviews for trailstone insurance on reddit communities and liked the idea of working with a local, independent agency without getting a flurry of phone calls after requesting quotes. the process was astonishingly fast: online request for quote, phone call a couple hours later with a few questions for more detail, an email with a video review the next day, then a 15 minute phone call with my new agent christy beesley. with minimal effort on my part, christy researched dozens of insurance companies and found me home insurance with more coverage for less money, cheaper auto insurance, and a separate wind/hail policy...all while saving me about $700!! I couldn't be happier with christy beesley and trailstone insurance. my only regret is that i didn't do it sooner!”

“Changing insurance companies. My car insurance was due and I had bundled my cars with my house. I received an updated policy from my previous insurance company and was surprised by the cost. I had been with this company for 33 years. Then I saw a Facebook post from Dave Ramsey about insurance and I filled out the form that was attached. The next day Sylvie Shook from Trailstone Insurance Group contacted me and I gave her the coverage amounts, the deductible cost and the total cost of my policy and she was able to save me over $2,000 for my bundled insurance. Sylvie Shook is awesome to work with.”

“Cody provided exceptional support in setting up our insurance policies—extremely knowledgable, efficient, friendly, and professional! I highly recommend Trailstone Insurance Group!”

“Jennifer carefully assembled the most cost effective package of insurance products for me. Her knowledge and expertise was very much appreciated.”

“Trevor Johnson was very easy to deal with. Explained what I was looking for and he went to work. Saved me over $500 on my car insurance. The whole process was very smooth. Thanks Trevor”

“Saved me over $100 on a 6 month auto rate. Calling Progressive directly got me nowhere. Gabe had it handled in minutes and was very knowledgeable .”

“When I moved to Colorado, I was shell shocked to see how much more my auto insurance was going to be compared to where I lived previously. Having had very frustrating conversations with insurance companies I reached out through Ramsey Trusted insurance and got connected to Trailstone Insurance and Trevor Johnson. Working for me, Trevor was able to secure a auto insurance policy that was so much more affordable than I thought was going to possible. Trevor was very patient and understanding, knowledgeable in all things insurance, and easy to work with.”

“Had a great time with Mike, he got me a very low price compared to other places that I had called and was very quick to get to work as well.”

“Grant was amazing on getting a great rate for both car and home insurance. He save me about $700 a year between both. Thank you for your help Grant!”

“Our experience with Trailstone has been amazing! They are so patient and thorough with their research and found us the best rate- they cut both our home and auto insurance rates in half! Christy has been a dream to work with and I would recommend Trailstone every time!”

“Trevor has been excellent to work with. I received super fast service as he explained the details with me. I am thrilled to have started using Trailstone Insurance Group as they found me insurance for about 1/3 of what I was paying with my previous policy, I highly recommend you consider them.”

“Jesse was great to work with. Responds super fast, got us a great plan. Very happy with my experience.”

“Was connected with Trailstone through Ramsey Solutions to look at maximize my insurance coverage at the best pricing. They reached out quickly to provide great options for my insurance needs that ended up saving me over $1000 over the next year.”

“I found Trailstone Insurance Group through Dave Ramsey's Financial Peace University website. I trust their referrals and once again I was not disappointed. I had the pleasure of working with Brian Stanley who did an outstanding job helping me find much less expensive auto, home, and umbrella policies. Not only was he professional and knowledgeable, he was thoughtful and kind. His follow-through was stellar! I loved the way he explained things and I really appreciated his patience with me. THANK YOU BRIAN!!!”

“cody was able to save me almost a thousand a year on car insurance. his excellent communication skills made this insurance change super easy for me and i recommend using him and his company! he’s very goaty”

“Christy Beesley helped me find better car and home insurance rates and walked me through the whole process of canceling my previous coverage - in a matter of days! She was so knowledgeable and kind. Highly recommend Trailstone for any of your insurance needs!”

“I was very pleased with the professionalism I got from Cody at Trailstone insurance group.The transition from my old insurance to my new insurance went very very smoothly, how much money I saved on our mortgage insurance by switching and I would definitely use them again if I need to. Thank you so much for all your help!”

“Cody was incredibly helpful with my first time getting car insurance. He was honest and extremely personable. They give you all of the information needed to make the most informed decision possible! Fully recommend :)”

“Cody was very attentive, flexible and considerate in finding the right insurance providers that met my current needs. I couldn't have had a better experience.”

“Brian was so helpful and flexible with my schedule! He helped me to get the best rate for car insurance then after a hectic move helped me with new centers insurance. Would highly recommend so many options provided and clarity for me who did not understand insurance at all. Thank you Brian Stanley and Trailstone insurance.”

“I couldn't be more pleased with the results that Matt and Trailstone provided me. Like many military families, I've been with USAA for over 45 years. I always thought they had my best interests at heart and were doing everything they could to take care of me at reasonable rates, so I never even bothered to look for alternatives. When Matt provided me quotes, I was stunned to have options that were half the cost of USAA, and provided better coverages for both auto and home insurance. Matt is very polite and respectful, organized and efficient, the whole process took just two days. I've already sent my Mother and my Brother to Matt and he's currently taking care of them now. I give Matt and Trailstone my highest recommendation! His service is so needed in this environment of rising cost. Thank you Matt!!”

“Trailstone Insurance Group is extremely professional and was very helpful in finding insurance to fit our needs. Not to mention we are saving hundreds every month thanks to them. Matt Rodgers was so easy to work with and explained everything we had questions about. Very positive experience and would highly recommend!”

“Switching my car insurance used to feel like a nightmare, but the team here made it so easy! From the first minute on the phone with Micheal, he took care of everything without any hassle or confusing jargon. He found me a better rate and walked me through each step with a smile. If you want friendly people who actually value your time and make the process completely stress-free, this is the team to call. Highly recommended!”

“Great experience, super quick, almost effortless, and at no cost to myself! My homeowners insurance rate spiked and I reached out to use an insurance broker, something I’d never done before. I was quickly connected with Jesse O. and within a few days I already had a plan that was significantly less than my original plan and with almost 2-3x the coverage. Cannot recommend enough!”

“Our experience with Trailstone was great! Our agent Christy Beesley made the process easy and quick. We were able to switch both car and home insurance to get better coverage and save money! She took care of everything with minimal work and time on our end and was very nice to work with. She communicated everything throughout the process and got us new coverage quickly. 100% would recommend going with Trailstone. It was so much easier than trying to shop around ourselves and it saved us the hassle of dealing with insurance salespeople. Thanks Trailstone!”