Skip to main content

Captive vs Independent Insurance Agents: What’s the Difference?

October 16th, 2025

0 min. read

By Mark Rodgers

Confused about which type of insurance agent to work with? You’re not alone—there’s a lot of misinformation out there. In this video, we break down the real differences between captive, direct, and independent agents, and why your choice could impact both your coverage and your wallet.

✔️ Captive Agents: Work for one company (like State Farm or Allstate).
✔️ Direct Writers: Sell insurance online or through call centers (like USAA or Amica).
✔️ Independent Agents: Work with multiple carriers to find you the best rate and coverage.

Welcome to Trailstone

How can we help today?

I’m new here

Get a quote

One request, 40+ A-rated carriers compared for you. What would you like to protect?

Start my quote
No spamNo bait-and-switchReal agent

I’m already a client

Manage my policy

Skip the hold music. Pick what you need and it goes straight to our service team.

Visit the Service Center